How our definition of freedom has changed..เสรีภาพก็ยังถกเถี่ยงจนทุกวันนี้

ในห้อง 'Black Hole' ตั้งกระทู้โดย VisionPower, 14 พฤศจิกายน 2018.

  1. VisionPower

    VisionPower เป็นที่รู้จักกันดี

    7 ตุลาคม 2016
    "How our definition of freedom has changed". .. เสรีภาพยังถกเถี่ยงจนทุกวันนี้
    (13Nov2018, World Economic Forum)

    The ancient democrats wouldn’t think you live in a democracy

    More slaves... more democracy?

    He points out that "modern" states simply cannot operate in the same way as ancient Athens did. After all, if the city of Chicago were to have an assembly that only 20 percent of the adult population showed up to, like in ancient Athens, they would have to find room for 300,000 people to have a meeting. The physical size of modern states also exacerbates the problem.

    the increasing variety of options available to people at the dawn of the modern age and impossibility of micromanaging everybody's affairs lead to the idea of personal liberties that the state shouldn't infringe on. Constant also thought the state would have a hard time trying to infringe on these rights anyway since all of the familiar means of repression were originally designed for small city states. When he said that in 1819 he might have been right.

    So, is voting is overrated?

    Not at all, as Constant argues that exercising our political liberty is the only way to guarantee personal freedom. What he rejects is the idea that a modern society requires ancient liberties, like direct participation all the time, to be free. Indeed, he blames the worst excesses of the French Revolution on attempts to bring the wrong liberties to France. Colin Woodard suggests in his book, American Nations, that a similar thing happened in the early years of the United States when the democratically elected John Adams restricted free speech.

    The democracies that we live in today are entirely different from the ones in the ancient world. While it isn't possible for everybody to serve as a magistrate or vote on every issue that affects society, it is possible for us to govern ourselves, choose representatives, and assure our freedoms through the democratic process. While we can't be free in the same way as the Greeks were, we might have it better now anyway.